Back

Republic vs. De Los Angeles [SEPARATE OPINION, CONCURRING, BARREDO, J.]

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, MIGUEL TOLENTINO, SR., ZOILA DE CHAVEZ, DEOGRACIAS MERCADO, MARIANO PANTOJA, GUILLERMO MERCADO, AGAPITO REYES, ISIDRO BESAS, LEONA LACHICA, ELENO MACALINDONG, DIONISIO MACALINDONG, DOROTEO SARA, JOAQUIN CAUNCERAN, VIRGILIO AGUILAR, FELIX DUMAN, PIO BACULI, ANTERO APOLINAR, FLAVIANO CURZADO, ROSENDO IBAÑEZ, ARCADIO GONZALES, FELIX BORJA AND BLAS BASCO, petitioners, vs. HON. JAIME DE LOS ANGELES, Judge, Court of First Instance of Batangas, Branch III, Balayan, Batangas; AYALA Y CIA, AND/OR HACIENDA CALATAGAN AND ALFONSO ZOBEL, respondents

G.R. No. L-26112 | 1972-04-11

CONCURRING OPINION  
 
BARREDO, J.: 
 
I concurred in the resolution of October 4, 1971 and I find no cogent reason why I should change my vote now that the motions for the reconsideration thereof are being denied. Except for the matter of the alleged disqualification of the writer of this separate opinion to act with the Court in this case, which, anyway, the undersigned already considered best to explain in his separate opinion concurring in the resolution of October 4, 1971, there are no points of consequence raised therein which have not been previously considered and ruled upon in the aforesaid resolution,...