Back

Panizales, et al vs. Palmares, et al

GERONIMO PANIZALES, ELIAS PANIZALES and VICENTE PANIZALES, plaintiffs-appellees, vs. VALERIO PALMARES, VALENTIN ESPINO, JOSE DINEROS, in his capacity as Provincial Sheriff, defendants, VALERIO PALMARES, defendant-appellant.

G.R. No. L-32143 | 1972-10-31

D E C I S I O N


FERNANDO, J:

The controversy in this appeal from a lower court decision is between plaintiff, now appellee, Geronimo Panizales, who would base his claim to the disputed lot as purchaser in a private sale on March 19, 1958 and defendant Valerio Palmares, the sole appellant, who bought the same at the public auction sale on March 16, 1961 by virtue of a writ of execution issued at the instance of defendant Valentin Espino, the judgment creditor who was the prevailing party in a suit against the original owner thereof, a certain Amado Panizales. 1 The lower court decision, now on appeal, was in favor of the plaintiff...