Back

Dumanon vs Butuan City Rural Bank, 119 SCRA 193

ZOILA DUMANON, SEVERINA DUMANON, PEDRO REBOYON, VICTORIANA MONTILLA, REFERADO FURIA, ROSARIO DE LAWAN, FELICIDAD DE DULAYBA and OLYMPIO DULAYBA, plaintiffs-appellants, vs. BUTUAN CITY RURAL BANK, BUTUAN CITY REGISTER OF DEEDS, FELISA AZOTE VDA. DE DUMANON, RACQUEL DUMANON, ROSARIO DUMANON, ERNESTO DUMANON, CARLOS CURILAN and RUFINA NARANJO, defendants-appellees.

G.R. No. L-27675 | 1982-12-15

D E C I S I O N 


DE CASTRO, J.: 

Appeal from the order dated September 10, 1966 (pp. 60-63, Record on Appeal, p. 10, Rollo) of the Court of First Instance of Agusan dismissing Civil Case No. 1029 of said court on a motion to dismiss filed by defendants Carlos Curilan and Rufina Naranjo (pp. 39-45, Record on Appeal, p. 10, Rollo). 

The motion to dismiss alleged the following grounds: 

"1. THAT THE CAUSE OF ACTION IS BARRED BY STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS (Rule 16, Sec 1, Par. (f) of the Rules of Court); 

"2. THAT THE COMPLAINT STATES NO CAUSE OF ACTION (par [g]); 

"3. THAT THE SUIT IS BETWEEN MEMBERS OF THE SAME FAMILY...