Back

Filipinas Port Services, Inc. Vs. National Labor Relations Comm, Et Al.

FILIPINAS PORT SERVICES, INC., petitioner, vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, PATERNO LIBOON, SEGUNDO AQUINO, JOVITO BULAY, DOMINGO NAVOA, DELFIN BERMEJO, CELEDONIO MANGUBAT, ALBERTO MAHINAY, SR., TEODULO SILAYA, SANTOS ARGUIDO, JUANITO LABANON, FLORENCIO MIRANTES, LUCIO BARRERA, VICENTE GILDORE, LEON FUENTES, CASIMIRO MAGSAYO, FERNANDO MORIENTE, MATIAS ORBITA, SR., FRANCISCO PARDILLO, ILDEFONSO JUMILLA AND JOSE CANTONJOS, respondents. Yap, Ocampo & Associates for petitioner. Porfirio S. Daclan for private respondents.

G.R. No. 97237 | 1991-08-16

D E C I S I O N


PARAS, J.:

This is a petition for clarification with prayer for preliminary injunction filed by Filipinas Port Services, Inc. (hereinafter referred to as Filport) seeking to clarify two conflicting decisions rendered by this Court in cases involving identical or similar parties, facts and issues.

The antecedent facts of the case are as follows:

In view of the government policy which ordained that cargo handling operations should be limited to only one cargo handling operator-contractor for every port (under Customs Memorandum Order 28075, later on superseded by General Port Regulations of the Philippine Ports...