Back

Development Bank Of The Philippines Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

DEVELOPMENT BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, PINES HOTEL GENERAL WORKERS' UNION-ALU, VIRGINIA ABAD, DOLORES AQUINO, JOHNNY CASTA?EDA, ALICE ICASIANO, PATRICIA MORRISEY, CLARITA OCASIO, EVELYN GENOVE, EUSEBIO MANIBOG, JULIETA LUNA, ANGELITA PONCE, EMMANUEL PELAYO, REMEDIOS TABUNDA, JERRY AQUICIO, GLORIA MAPANAO, EDWIN ANGWAY, ERNESTO CASTRO, NELSON CONSTANTINO, FLORENTINO LAGMAN, EMMANUEL SONGCUYA, RECTO ALAWAS, MARJOE ALEGRE, OLIVIA ANTIPOLO, LYDIA AQUICIO, RIZALINA AUXILIO, RENATO AGLUBAT, CHARLES BALDOS, ERNESTO BILOG, ESTHER BIONGCOG, DIOSDADO BUAN, MARGARITA CAMPO, LUCRESIA CACHERO, JUANITA DESEAR, FLORDELIZA DELA PAZ, RENATO DE VERA, ERIC DIZON, JULIETA ENRIQUEZ, DOLORES ESCUADRA, HILDA ELLEANA, ARSENIO FERNANDO, ZALDY GALUZ, BRAULIO GIRON, MERCEDES GOROSPE, EVANGELINE GUIMPOL, CARLITO KARGANILLA, PRESCILO LUNA, AGUSTIN LANUEVO, INOCENSIA LAYSON, MARINA MEDENILLA, VENANCIO MENDOZA JUDY HELEN MENDOZA, FRANCISCO MIRANDA, PASCUAL RHADELL, JOHN PECSON, LUZVIMINDA RABANILLO, ALVIN RIVANO, THELMA TILOS, AMELIA AGUILAR, SUSAN BAGGAO, FRANCISCO BAHATAN, OLIVER BENITO, CYNTHIA, BILAG, JEFFRY BUGAOAN, DOUGLAS CALASICAS, LETICIA CASTA?EDA, ROMEO GAWALING, PEPITO DELA CRUZ, GABRIEL DE VERA, ANDREW DOMINGO, ROMULO FELIZARDO, ELVIS JALECO, EVELYN JINGCO, RANDOLPH HAYA, RUBEN NEMEDEZ, RODOLFO PARTOSA, GEORGE SISON, SAMUEL REYES, RENATO RULIAMAS, ROBERTO VILLANDA, LORETA YUNG, ANTONIO ALBANO, AMADO ARELIANO, ERNESTO ALBALATE, RUDY AUXILIO, ENRIQUE AGUINALDO, WILFREDO ANCHETA, MARIVIC AROMIN, AIDA BAGWAN, ROLANDO BALBIN, DANILO BALTAZAR, SATURNINO BUCASAS, ROMERO BUCYOT, ABRAHAM CAALAMAN, CERIOLO CARRERA, ALBERTO CREDO, JOSEPHINE CARBONEL, ANTONIO CONSOLACION, LORETO CORNEL, ANTONIO CORTEZ, IRENEO CUARESMA, JOHNSON CENTENO, LOUIE CORNEL, PACIFICO DE CASTRO, GENARO DELA PAZ, ALFREDO DEL PILAR, LINO DEUTSCH, LUZVIMINDA DE GUZMAN, ELIZABETH DANGIAPO, VALENTINO DELA CRUZ, TERESITA ESPERITU, NOLI ESPERIDA, HERNANDO ESPERANZA, BARTOLOME FLORES, VIVENCIO FUENTES, JULIE FAMORCA, DEO GUIMALAN, ANGEL GRAJO, ANSELMO, GOYONE, DEMCY GALIMBA, JOSE GO, EDWIN GUTIEREZ, LEO HALOG, REYNALDO JAMISON, GARY JAVATI, ROSANAH LAPID, RODOLFO LIBAYAN, BALDOMERO LAROYA, REYNALDO LOVINA, DELIA LIWALIW, JAIME MANGAOANG, SHIRLEY MANGONON, ANDY MINGOA, CLODUALDO MEDENILLA, ABRAHAM MORALES, NENITA, MONARES, FERDINAND MACAYAN, ALFONSO MAICO, RODRIGO MAMANGON, ALETA MILLETE, MANUEL NAVALTA, FLORANTE NOVICIO, RUFO NASOL, SAMUEL NOVESTERA, WILLIAM OLARTE, CONRADO OLPINDO, ROMULO PADAOAN, JUANITO PERALTA, ROMEO POSADAS, RAYMUNDO QUIRIT, EDWIN RABANILLO, ALEXANDER RANCHEZ, FLORANTE ROTOR, BALLY RAZON, NIDA RIZO, ROMULO RIMANDO, EMERLINDA RITUALO, TERESITA ROSALIN, CESAR SAGUN, WILLY SALINDONG, ROSALINA SARMIENTO, NARDITO SIBAYAN, DEO TABLIGAN, RODRIGO TORRES, DAMIANA TOLETE, WILLIAM TORRES, EDUARDO TABUNDA, DINAH UDAN, JOSEPHINE VALERIO, OSCAR VALERIO, GREGORIO VELASCO, DANNY VINLUAN, JIMMY VALERIO, CATALINA ZAMORA, JUAN ZAMORA, REMEDIOS ABUL, SAMUEL ALIMBUYAO, MAX ALIGAN, REYNALDO AMADEO, PEDRITO APILADO, ARTEMIO BARLOLONG, JERRY BIONGCOG, REYNALDO BUCSIT, VIVINCIO BUNUAN, RONALDO BUELA, JULIETA CALICDAN, HARRY CALVO, LORENZO CALASICAS, REMEGIO CAMBA, RICARDO CARACAS, JAIME CASUGA, SAMUEL CARIDAD, WILLIAM DE CASTRO, FELIPA DE NIEVA, GLICERIA ESTADIAN, NORMAN ELEGADO, JULIANA FERRER, ROSITA FLORDELIZ, FELICIANO GANZON, JAIME HULIGANGA, PRECILLA JAVIER, DANILO JAMINEZ, SALVADOR LALATA, FRANCISCO LARANANG, BERNARDINO LARANO, PARK FEE LEONG, MARINA LOVINA, DENNIS LAGO, MOISES MACADAEG, ELIGEO MACARANAS, GEORGE MANUEL, MOISES MEDINA, ENRIQUE MADAYAG, RODOLFO MAYUYO, EDUARDO MANAOIS, ELIZABETH PANGANIBAN, EDUARDO PERALTA, ROGELIO PEREZ, GABRIEL PONSO, EDITHA POSADAS, RODOLFO RAMOS, REYNALDO RIMANDO, ROLF RUSCHENSCHEMIDT, EFRAIM SARMIENTO, JOSE SURPO, BEN TAMONDONG, AMANTE TELLES, JESS VALDEZ, ARNULDO VENTURA, LETECIA VERAY, JUELITO VIRAY, ILUMINADA ABRERA, ANDRES BANDAY, ROSARIO BAUTISTA, MILAGROS BILOG, ROLANDO COCAL, TERESITA CORAL, LOLITA GARIEJO, AVELINO LAZARTE, FLORENTINA MATA, LEONARDO MARIANO, JOSE MARZAN, FREDELITO OMO, VIRGILIO DELA PE?A, ARNOLD RANTE, LUCENA TAVARRA, ANTONIA TIBALAO, TOMAS ABUGAN, URSULA AKIA, JOSE ARCENAL, DIONISIO APILADO, FELIMON CACCAM, RICARDO CASTILLO, MAMERTO CALO, ANASTACIO COCAL, ANGELINE DAMASO, PEDRO DELA PE?A, ARTURO DE GUZMAN, ANTONIO DOMINGO, ROLUMO ELEFANTE, FLORENCIO FINULIAR, ARNULFO GALVEZ, CAMILO GARCIA, RODOLFO GARCIA, LAMBERTO GERALDE, ERNESTO GONZALES, JUAN GRIBA, VALENTIN GANSOWEN, DOMINADOR GUTIEREZ, LARRY HAYA, JOHN INIGUID, JOSEPH LAM-OSEM, MENANDRO MALONZO, FELIPE MAPILE, VENANCIO MACADANGDAND, ALBINO MALIBAGO, ROMEO OLIVA, MARIANO PASCUA, RENATO PAYONGAYONG, ROBERTO PERALTA, DOMINIC PUCKETT, ISABELO RAMOS, MIGUEL RIVERA, BERNARDO TIAM, JAIME VALENCIANO, JR., NATY AGOO, CRISTINA ALEO, NORMA ANTOC, JIMMY AMBATCAN, DAVID ABELLERA, RICARDO BANCUYO, AMADOR BAUTISTA, ENRIQUE BAUTISTA, GEORGE CALDERON, SAMUEL CACDAC, RUDY CAMBOD, JOSE CASTILLO, ALFREDO CATBAGAN, CONCHITA CASTILLO, FLORENCIO CORPUZ, ORLANDO CONDAYA, JOSEPHINE CULBENGAN, EMPERATRIZ DELIGERO, SINFOROSO DELA PE?A, MARIANO DELA PE?A, CYNTHIA DE VERA, EDWIN DUCAT, ORLANDO ESTIPONA, FELIZ FERNANDEZ, RICARDO FONTANOSA, VICTORINA GACAYAN, NICOLAS GARCIA, CELEDONIO HALILI, ELIZA IBEA, AIDA ITLIONG, EFREN ITLIONG, PAUL LAM-OSEN, FELIPE LOBIEN, ARNEL MANDAP, REY OJASCASTRO, JACINTO PACLAYAN, TEOTIMO PAGALAN, HERMINIGILDO ROSARIO, SUSAN SAN JOSE, JOSE SANCHEZ, CELSO SORIANO, RODOLFO SOTERO, ERWIN URBIEN, and FLORENTINO ZACARIAS, respondents.

G.R. No. 106655 | 1994-09-01

D E C I S I O N


VITUG, J.:

This petition for certiorari, invoking Rule 65 of the Rules of Court, challenges the decision, dated 16 April 1991, as well as the resolution, dated 31 July 1992, of respondent National Labor Relations Commission ("NLRC").

Resort Hotel Corporation ("RHC") was the former owner and operator of the Pines Hotel in Baguio City, where private respondents were employed. The property was hypothecated to petitioner Development Bank of the Philippines ("DBP"). When RHC failed to comply with its obligations, DBP foreclosed on the mortgage. Following the foreclosure, Hotel Development Corporation ("HDC"), a subsidiary of...