Back

Trinidad De Ayala Vs. Antonio M. Barretto 033 Phil 538

TRINIDAD DE AYALA ET AL., plaintiffs-appellants, vs. ANTONIO M. BARRETTO ET AL., defendants-appellees.

G.R. No. 9966 | 1916-02-14

D E C I S I O N


TRENT, J.:

This is a suit for a permanent injunction against the erection and operation of a combined brewery and ice plant on Calle General Solano in the city of Manila, on the ground that it will be a nuisance. From a judgment denying the relief prayed for, the plaintiffs have appealed.

The twenty-two plaintiffs are either residents or property owners on Calle General Solano. Twelve of them are actual residents of the street and of these twelve, six are lessees of property owned by other plaintiffs.

This street connects Echague and Aviles Streets. All three parallel the Pasig River. Echague is almost wholly given...