Back

Bataan Shipyard & Engineering Corp. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, et al.

BATAAN SHIPYARD AND ENGINEERING CORPORATION, petitioner vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, NAFLU and PASTOR, ABAQUITA, EDUARDO ABDON, WILFREDO ABDON, BENIGNO ABOG, DELFIN ABUJEN, DOMINGO ACOL, MARIANO ADATO, PEDRO ADENO, RODRIGO AGBANLOG, IRENEO ALACIDA, RICARDO ALINSOD, NORBERTO ALMADIN, DIOSDADO ALVAREZ, MARIANO ALVAREZ, FEDELINO APOLINAR, ALFREDO AQUINO, MARTIN AQUINO, EDUARDO ASUNCION, EMILIO ATIENZA, ARTURO AVILA, JESUS AYDALLA, ROMEO AYTIN, OPENIANO BADILLES, FELIPE BAJAYA, NARCISO BALANZA, JAIME BALLESTEROS, DOMINGO BARNACHEA, EFIGENIO BARNACHEA, TEODOLFO BARRO, JUAN BASUEL, TEOFILO BATERINA, EFREN BATHAN, PEDRO BATHAN, CLEMENTE RAUL, MARIO RAUL, ALEX BAUTISTA, FELIMON BAUTISTA, WILSON BAUTISTA, ARSENIO BERNALES, LETICIA BLANCO, DIOSDADO BONDOC, PEDRO BRIELA, JESUS BUELOS, JOSE BUENAVENTE, RENATO BUGAY, MIGUEL BUMAGAT, RAMON BUMAGAT, ANDRES CALMA, ISMAEL CALUMNO, LIBNOS CANAVERAL, FEDERICO CAPILI, RESTITUTO CAPILI, GODOFREDO CAPIT, BIENVENIDO CARREON, INOCENCIO CASTLLLO, JESUS CASTRO, CRISANTO CASUAYAN, ADEL CELESTINO, FULGENCIO CENTENO, SINFOROSO COFNEROS, FRANCISCO COLABRES, BENJAMIN CONDAYA, BENNY CONSTANTINO, PRUDENCIO CORDOVA, BONIFACIO CORONADO, ONOFRE CORTEZ, EDGARDO CIRSOSTOMO, AVELINO DELA CRUZ, BENJAMIN DELA CRUZ, CARLITO DELA CRUZ, EDUARDO CRUZ, RENATO CRUZ, RODOLFO CUADRANTE, TEOFILO CUEVAS, JAIME DACLITAN, PASCUAL DACU, RODRIGO DALINDIN, SOTERO DARILAG, ARTURO DAVID, FELIPE DAVID, REYNALDO DECENA, TEODOLFO DELIQUENA, NOLI DEOCAREZA, SIMPLICIO DETABLAN, EDGARDO DIANO, ALEXANDER DIMAFILES, FRANCISCO DOMINGO, FLAVIANO EBREO, RODRIGO EBREO, AVELINO ELQUERO, RAMON ELQUERO, DOMINADOR ENCARIAL, JUANITO ESPANOLA, CONRADO ESPIRITU, GREGORIO ESQUERDO, ESTEBAN ESQUERRA, RODOLFO FABILA, SALVADOR FABILA, RODOLFO FIGUEROA, DANILO FRANCISCO, ALBERTO GABRIEL, BASILIO GALAS, ALBERTO GARCIA, EDUARDO GARCIA, NICOLAS GARCIA, JOSE GERALDE, JR., CELESTINO GLEAN, CANDELARIA GOMEZ, ROY GRAJEDA, REYNALDO DE GUZMAN, ISAGANI HIPOLITO, NILO HURTADA, GILBERT IGLESIAS, CECILIO IGNACIO, JR., ERNESTO IGNACIO, LEONARDO ISLDRO, WILFREDO ISIP, BENJAMIN JACOBO, FELIPE JACOBO, ALFREDO SAN JOSE, VICENTE JOSE, LEOPOLDO DE JOYA, IGNACIO SAN JUAN, REYNALDO KABILING, ROBERTO LABIAN, PANRIQUITO LACUMBIS, DIOSCORO LACUNA, ALEJANDRO LAGAPA, EDUARDO LANTIN, ARTEMIO LAPIZ, ROMEO LARAL, ANTERITO LARGO, ERNESTO LAVERINTO, MARCIAL LEJARES, AMADO DE LEON, JR., EULOGIO LESACA, ROMEO DE LIMA, RODOLFO LORILLA, PEDRO LOVINIA, ULPIANO LOZANO, GASPAR MACALALAD, JAIME MADARANG, ANTONIO MADRID, ANDRES MAGNO, ARTURO MAGPOC, DANILO MALO, RODOLFO MANALAC, DANILO MANDAMI, FRANCISCO MANDANI, EDUARDO MANGILIMAN, JOVITO MANLAPID, JAIME MARCELINO, BENIGNO MARCHA, MANUEL MARCHA, JOSE MARIQUE, ELEUTERIO MARTINEZ, TEDORO MATOL, DIOSCORO MAYHAY, FRANCISCO MEDINA, ARMANDO MEJIA, FELICITO MENDEZ, AVELINO MENDOZA, FELINO MENDOZA, JULIAN MENDOZA, ROMEO MENZON, FERNANDO MONTABLO, FELIX MORILLO, DOMINGO NACOR, ELIZABETH NAGUIT, ROMEO NATIVIDAD, CATALINO NAVAROZA, FRANCISCO NAVAROZA, ALBERTO NEPOMUCENO, EDUARDO NICDAO, SANTOS NIERVES, FABIAN NOCEDA, ANTONIO OCAMPO, FERNANDO OLARTE, DANILO OLIVERIA, VIVENCIO OLIVERIA, RODOLFO PABLO, EUFEMIO PACUMIO, LUCIO PACUMIO, MAXIMO PADERNA, JOSE PADRE, CATALINO PANDALIS, SEVERINO PARAGAS, ERNESTO PASAG, HIPOLITO PEAPE, NENITO SAN PEDRO, SALVADOR PENALOZA, ARTHURO PICASO, ARMANDO PORTUGUEZ, CRISPIN POSADAS, ANASTACIO PURUGANAN, ARMANDO QUIJANO, CRISPIN QUINTO, VICTOR RAMIREZ, VICTORIANO RAMOS, CRISPO RAYA MIGUEL REAL, PEDRO REAL, DAMASO REALUBIT, EMILIO REGLOS, DAVID RELAYO, ELINO REMY, JOSE REONAL, ROLANDO REYES, SILVINO DELOS REYES, DEMOCRITO RICARDO, IRENEO RICO, BAYANI ROCO, PACIFICO ROCO, ARMANDO DANTE ROMERO, RUBEN ROMERO, ANTONIO ROQUE, CARMELINO ROQUE, BONIFACIO DEL ROSARIO, DOMINGO DEL ROSARIO, ALMARIO ROSETE, CLEMENTE RUBIA EDUARDO SABLAY, ANDRES SALAZAR, VICENTE SALEM, ROSAURO SALONGA, BIENVENIDO SALUD, MARVIN SALUD, ARTURO SALVADOR, BAYANI SANTOS, CARMELITO SANTOS, JOSE SANTOS, DANILO SANTOS, MELENCIO SAPNU, ROGELIO SARMIENTO, LEONARDO SILAYA, AMELITA DE SILVA, FENANDO SOBERANO, TEODORO SOLANO, RODOLFO SOLINAP, LORETO SOMERA, CRESENCIO SORIA, MARIANO SORIA, SALVADOR TAGLE, VERONICA TAMAYO, ROMEO TAMBALO, ELEUTERIO TANEZA, EDGARDO TAPANG, MARIANO TEMPRA, ALDREDO TERNIDA, ALMARIO TOLENTINO, REYNALDO TOLENTINO, CANDIDO TORRES, EDGARDO TUANO, RICARDO TUAZON, ANTONIO URBANO, NIMROD VALDERAMA, DANNY VALDEZ, ALBERTO DE VEGA, ARMANDO VELEZ, SEVERINO DE VERA, LAMBERTO VERDERA, ANTERO VERTUDAZO, MAXIMO VILLANUEVA, NICOLAS VILLARAMA, INOCENCIO VLLLENA, CATALINO VIRAY, JOSE VISDA, GREGORIO VITOBINA, BERNARDO YUMOL, ARNEL ZULUETA, respondents.

G.R. No. 102876 | 1997-03-04

D E C I S I O N


HERMOSISIMA, JR., J.:

This is a petition for certiorari and prohibition with prayer for the issuance of a writ of preliminary injunction seeking to nullify and set aside the Resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission's dated July 19, 1991 in Injunction Case No. 1429 entitled, "NAFLU and Pascual Dacu, et al. v. Bataan Shipyard and Engineering Corporation," as well as the Resolution dated October 30, 1991.

Petitioner Bataan Shipyard and Engineering Co., Inc. (BASECO for brevity) is a corporation duly organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the Philippines with principal office at Engineering...