Back

RP, Philippine Navy vs Navy Officers' Village. Homeowners' Assn, et al

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by CAPT. BERNARDO E. PATI?O, in lieu of CAPT. RUFO R. VILLANUEVA, in his capacity as COMMANDING: OFFICER OF THE BONIFACIO NAVAL STATION, PHILIPPINE NAVY, Petitioner, versus NAVY OFFICERS' VILLAGE. HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION, INC., and COMMODORE EDUARDO T. DOMINGO AFP (Ret.), B/GENERAL BRIGIDO PAREDES AFP (Ret.), COMMODORE HERNANITO GABALES AFP (Ret.), COMMODORE EDGARDO GALLOS AFP (Ret.), COMMODORE MARINO PANES AFP (Ret.), COMMODORE RUBEN DELA CRUZ AFP (Ret.), COMMODORE RODOLFO SIMON AFP (Ret.), B/GENERAL BRAULIO BALBAS AFP (Ret.), CAPT. JULIAN L. ADVINCULA PN (Ret.), CAPT. JESUS DURIAN PN (Ret.), CAPT. NARCISO M. LISTON PN (Ret.), CAPT. SOLOMON DABOR PN (Ret.), COL. ROGELIO S. SUBIDA JAGS (Ret.), COL. RMELINO GOJO PN (M) (Ret.), CAPT. PROCESO MALIGALIG PN (Ret.), MRS. MYRNA C. APOLINARIO, in behalf of CAPT. TOMAS APOLINARIO PN (Deceased) and MRS. TRINIDAD DE VERA in behalf of COMMANDER CELINO DE VERA (Deceased), Respondents.

G.R. No. 130008 | 2004-10-25

DECISION





CALLEJO, SR., J.:





Before us is a petition for review on certiorari of the Decision[1] of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 42203, dismissing the petition for certiorari to annul the Order[2] of the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Makati, Metro Manila, Branch 141, dated September 4, 1996, granting the motion of respondents Commodore Eduardo Domingo and Commodore Rodolfo Simon for a writ of preliminary mandatory injunction in Civil Case No. 93-3549.


The Antecedents

Officers of the Philippine Navy who were in the active service were allowed by the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) to lease and occupy a housing...