Back

Daniel Aninao, et al. vs. Asturias Chemical Industries, Inc.

DANIEL ANINAO REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE CATALINA ANINAO, MAMERTO A. ALCARAZ, REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE HERMOGENA ALCARAZ, TEODULFO ALCARAZ, ROMULO C. ALIPUSTAIN, FELIX ANINAO REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE ANTONIO ANINAO, NESTOR S. ANINAO, PERFECTO B. ANINAO, LUIS ATIENZA SR., RICARDO BASCUGUIN, RESTITUTO A. BARAL REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE TERESA BARAL GLORIOSO, MAURO B. BARANGAS, ORECULO M. BARANGAS, ESMAEL E. BATOCABE, ANGELINA D. BUCALIG, PRIMO B. CABRAL, RUFINO C. CABRAL, LEONILA CARAIG, ANSELMO M. CARINGAL REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE SUSANA R. CARINGAL, DEMETRIO M. CARINGAL REPRESENTED BY SON GLICERIO D. CARINGAL, LORIANO CARINGAL, MARCIAL M. CARINGAL, PEDRO C. CARINGAL, SIMPLICIO M. CARINGAL, TEODORA R. CARINGAL REPRESENTED BY SON ANGELITO R. CARINGAL, PABLITO M. CASTELO, VICENTE CASTELO, FELIX M. CASTILLO, LORENZO R. CASTROJERES REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE EMILIA M CASTROJERES, ZALDY M. CASTROJERES, FELICISIMO CUELLA, ROMEO B. DACILLO, VIVENCIO M. DE GUZMAN, CELEDONIO C. DE JESUS, DIOMEDES A. DE JESUS, EFREN C. DE JESUS REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE OFELIA DE JESUS, ISIDRO C. DE JESUS, PRISCO C. DE JESUS REPRESENTED BY MONICA M. DE JESUS, ZOSIMO C. DE JESUS BENIGNO DE LA VEGA REPRESENTED BY SON MAURO G. DE LA VEGA MIGUEL DE LA VEGA, NICASIO H. DELGADO, ABELIO DELOS REYES, ENGRACIO DE LOS REYES, ERNESTO R. DE LOS REYES, FELICIANO DE LOS REYES REPRESENTED BY SON MANOLO DE LOS REYES, SOFRONIO DE SAGUN REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE FLORENCIA J. DE SAGUN, NONILON DIMAISIP, MAURICIO K. ELLAO,BRIGIDA ENDOZO, GABRIEL ETRON, NARCISO ETRON, RODRIGO B. FAMILIAR, GAUDENCIO HERNANDEZ, VIRGILIO HERNANDEZ, GREGORIO D. ILAO, LEONCIA ILAO, AGUSTIN A. LOPEZ, TOMAS R. MACATANGAY REPRESENTED BY SON WENCESLAO A. MACATANGAY, EUGENIO C. MALALUAN, QUINTIN DV. MALALUAN, ANACLETO DG. MANALO REPRESENTED BY SON ANTONIO MANALO, ANCISLO MANALO, ATANACIO MANALO, CRISPINIANO MANALO, CRISPULO D. MANALO, DELIA D. MANALO, DOROTEO MANALO ISIDRO M. MANALO, QUIRICO D. MANALO, ROGELIO MANALO, RESTITUTO MARQUEZ, CATALINO I. MARASIGAN REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE VICTORIA MARASIGAN, EUFEMIO MARASIGAN, FRANCISCO C. MARASIGAN, REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE ELISEA MARASIGAN, PABLO C. MARASIGAN,PEDRO C. MARASIGAN, RUPERTO C. MARASIGAN REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE SATURNINA MARASIGAN, EUSEBIA C. MARCO, SENANDO C. MARCO, APOLONIO Z. MENDOZA, LORETO Z. MENDOZA REPRESENTED BY DAUGTHER NATALIA MENDOZA, MARIANO MENDOZA , PURIFICACION Z. MENDOZA, CASIANO MERCADO, FLORO D. MERCADO, GERMAN B. MERCADO, CASIANA NUEVO, MODESTA DV. PADILLA, CRISENCIA D. PANGANIBAN, LEONARDO A. PANGANIBAN REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE NELIA PANGANIBAN, RENATO D. PANGANIBAN, FELIXBERTO G. PASTORIN, ANASTACIA D. PENAFLORIDA, MAXIMO PENAFLORIDA, PORFIRIO B. RAMIREZ, DANTE DV. RASDAS, DANILO DV. RASDAS, VENANCIO DV. RASDAS REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE MARIA P. RASADZ, SOTERO H. RODRIGUEZ REPRESENTED BY SPOUSE PASTORA RODRIGUEZ, APOLONIO M. ROXAS, BERNABE M. ROXAS, ELISEO M. ROXAS, LEODEGARIO A. ROXAS, LEONILO P. ROXAS, MIGUEL D. SACDALAN, DEMETRIO P. VILLLARIN, and, NEMESIO P. VILLARIN, Petitioners, versus ASTURIAS CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES, INC., Respondent.

G.R. No. 160420 | 2005-07-28

THIRD DIVISION

D E C I S I O N 

GARCIA, J.: 

In this petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court, petitioners Daniel Aninao, et al., urge the reversal and setting aside of the following issuances of the Court of Appeals in CA G.R. SP No. 72201, to wit: 

1) Resolution dated December 11, 2002,[1] dismissing herein petitioners' earlier petition for review of the decision and resolution dated January 4, 2002 and July 2, 2002, respectively, of the Office of the President; and 

2) Resolution dated October 15, 2003,[2] denying petitioners' motion for reconsideration. 

The relevant facts are well laid...