Back

[2/3] Grace F. Munnsayac C. de Villa, et al. vs. Judge Antonio .Reyes , et al

[2/3] GRACE F. MUNSAYAC C. DE VILLA, LILY F. MUNSAYAC- SUNGA, and ROY PETER F. MUNSAYAC, Complainants, versus JUDGE ANTONIO C. REYES, Respondent.

A.M. NO. RTJ-05-1925 (A.M. OCA IPI No. 00-989-RTJ) | 2006-06-26

In refutation of the aforementioned evidence, Judge Caguioa presented the affidavits of Melita Salinas, and several others, all of which were adopted as their direct testimonies. A summary of the relevant portions of their respective testimonies follows: 

1. Melita Salinas, Docket Clerk 3, Br.4, RTC, Baguio City, in her affidavit, (Exh. "10-A" & "10-A-1") declared being the custodian of all records of some 169 special proceedings cases being heard ex-parte since April 2000; that of that number, 138 cases were heard by Atty. Cristeta Flores, while Judge Caguioa, assisted by Carmen Diaz and Teodora Paquito, heard the remaining 31....