Back

Protacio Banguilan, et al. vs. CA, et al

PROTACIO BANGUILAN, NARCISO BANGUILAN, ELENA B. SANUCO, CAMILO BANGUILAN, MELITA GUINTAYON, NIEVES BALAGASAY, ESTEFANIA BANGUILAN, ERNESTINA B. BALABBO, LORNA B. ATUAN, JUANITA B. ONG and JOSE B. BANGUILAN, Petitioners, versus COURT OF APPEALS, JUDGE ALFREDO VERGARA, RTC, Branch 22 Cabagan, Isabela, BRIGIDA MANALO-VELASCO, PEDRO MANALO, SIMEONA M. BUNAGAN, JACINTO MANALO, JR., MERLITA MANALO-TACCAD, REYNALDO BACULI, DOMINADOR LAMAN, and JOEY TALAUE, Respondents.

G.R. No. 165815 | 2007-04-27

                                              D E C I S I O N


CARPIO MORALES, J.:


Assailed via Petition for Certiorari is the Court of Appeals Decision[1] of September 30, 2004 affirming the Order[2] of July 25, 2002 of the Regional Trial Court (RTC), Branch 22, Cabagan, Isabela which dismissed the Amended Complaint for Cancellation/Annulment of Title and Damages filed by petitioners against respondents.

In issue is whether, under the facts of the case, petitioners' cause of action was for cancellation/annulment of titles or...