Back

Heirs of Sofia Nanaman Lonoy, et al. vs. Sec. of Agrarian Reform, et al.

HEIRS OF SOFIA NANAMAN LONOY, NAMELY, MANUEL N. LONOY, OSCAR N. LONOY, WARREN N. LONOY, EXCELINO N. LONOY, EDGAR N. LONOY, VICTOR N. LONOY, APOLLO N. LONOY, GEMMA N. LONOY-SAMSON, HEIRS OF RODOLFO N. LONOY (ISABEL A. LONOY, ISABELITA A. LONOY-YOUNG, WINONA A. LONOY, RODERICK A. LONOY, NANCY A. LONOY-PAYNAEN, ROBERT LONOY, ROMMEL A. LONOY, RAFAEL A. LONOY, ZENAIDA LONOY-OPADA, HONEYLYN A. LONOY, MARITES LONOY CABURNAY, AND RODOLFO LONOY, JR.), HEIRS OF CORNELIA NANAMAN ADIS/ASEQUIA, NAMELY, HEIRS OF ELSA N. ADIS, BRICCIO N. ADIS, TOMAS N. ADIS, ROMY N. ADIS, JUSTINO N. ADIS, MERCITA N. ASEQUIA, AND TOMASITA N. ASEQUIA, HEIRS OF VICENTE NANAMAN (LUDEM NANAMAN, ET AL.), HEIRS OF MANUELA NANAMAN AMARGA, NAMELY, HEIRS OF CLARITA AMARGA-UBGUIA (VERLITO A. UBGUIA, DANILO A. UBGUIA, ASTERIO A. UBGUIA, AND CARLO A. UBGUIA), HEIRS OF ACOLON AMARGA (ALMIRANTE AMARGA, SPARTACUS AMARGA, MELVIN AMARGA, AND RODRIGO AMARGA), ALONSO N. AMARGA, HERDA N. AMARGA, DELOS MIMBA AMARGA-TOGONON, HEIRS OF ASCONA AMARGA UBAGAN (DEMOSTHENES A. UBAGAN, ET AL.), HEIRS OF NICODEMO N. AMARGA (JIMMY AMARGA, MARIETTA AMARGA, BENIGNO AMARGA, NICODEMO AMARGA, JR., ALMA AMARGA, FELIX AMARGA, ADOR AMARGA, LYDIA AMARGA, JUDY AMARGA, LOLOT AMARGA, AND MADONNA AMARGA), HEIRS OF ATANACIO NANAMAN AMARGA (GLORIOSA A. APOR, NESTOR AMARGA, NORVILLA AMARGA, GENITA AMARGA, AND GILMA AMARGA), HEIRS OF OLIVA AMARGA-BADELLES (JOSE I. BADELLES, JIMBO BADELLES, JOHNSON BADELLES, ALITA BADELLES-JALAGAT, NINIAN BADELLES, JONA A. BADELLES, CEFERINO A. BADELLES, OLIVER BADELLES, OHARA A. BADELLES, MARIA BADELLES, SARAH A. BADELLES, JEBA A. BADELLES, AND MICHAELA A. BADELLES), AND HEIRS OF MANSUETO N. AMARGA (EDNA AMARGA - SURVIVING SPOUSE OF JESSE AMARGA, DEÑA AMARGA-MAGHINAY, AND MARLON AMARGA), HEIRS OF GENARA NANAMAN SAKALL, NAMELY, AMPARO SAKALL-DURANO, BENEDICTO N. SAKALL, ISABELITA N. SAKALL, FRANCISCA SAKALL MARQUINA, HONORIO N. SAKALL, VIRGINIA SAKALL ESTANISLAO, AND NORMA N. SAKALL, HEIRS OF JULIETA NANAMAN, NAMELY, HEIRS OF JAIME NANAMAN/RIVERA (ANASTASIA LAUGAM NANAMAN - SURVIVING SPOUSE, DULSORA NANAMAN, AND GUILLERMO NANAMAN), HEIRS OF PIO NANAMAN/ROA (WILMA NANAMAN, ALFREDO NANAMAN, DELIA NANAMAN, SALVADOR NANAMAN, HEIRS OF RAUL NANAMAN, EVELYN NANAMAN, VIOLA NANAMAN, EDITHA NANAMAN, PINKY NANAMAN, AND ALEXANDER NANAMAN), HEIRS OF GREGORIO NANAMAN/DACAMPO (VICTOR NANAMAN, VICENTE NANAMAN, GREGORIO NANAMAN, JR., AND VIRGIE NANAMAN), AND HEIRS OF ORLANDO NANAMAN (EMILIA G. NANAMAN - SURVIVING SPOUSE, ALEX NANAMAN, EMMA NANAMAN, HEIRS OF GEORGINA NANAMAN, GEORGE NANAMAN, RAMIL NANAMAN, AND CAROLYN NANAMAN), HEIRS OF ROSARIO NANAMAN RUEDAS, NAMELY, HEIRS OF BERNARDO N. RUEDAS (JULIA RUEDAS, JONATHAN RUEDAS, MARLON RUEDAS, MARIVIC RUEDAS, EDITHA RUEDAS, AND MARGIE RUEDAS-POGOY), AND HEIRS OF JOSE "FEBE" NANAMAN (SOCORRO NANAMAN, AIDA NANAMAN, LERMA NANAMAN-MORALES, EDUARDO NANAMAN, JOSEFA NANAMAN, MARISA NANAMAN, ARTURO NANAMAN, AND MARYFLOR NANAMAN), AND ATTY. ELPEDIO CABASAN AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE INTESTATE ESTATE OF GREGORIO NANAMAN, PETITIONERS, VS. SECRETARY OF AGRARIAN REFORM, LAND REGISTRATION AUTHORITY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM ADJUDICATION BOARD (DARAB), LAND BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES, HEIRS OF NECIFORO CABALUNA, HEIRS OF ABDON MANREAL, TRANQUILINA C. MANREAL, TITO L. BALLER, HEIRS OF HERCULANO C. BALORIO, ALICIA B. MANREAL, FELIPE D. MANREAL, SALVACION MANREAL, HEIRS OF DOMINGO N. RICO, HEIRS OF DOMINGO V. RICO, MACARIO VELORIA, HEIRS OF CUSTODIO M. RICO, HEIRS OF CLEMENTE M. RICO, MARTILLANO D. OBESO, HEIRS OF PABLO F. RICO, RESPONDENTS, CITY OF ILIGAN, HEIRS OF JUAN NANAMAN, HEIRS OF LIMBANIA CABILI MERCADO, HEIRS OF MARIANO ANDRES CABILI, RESPONDENTS/UNWILLING CO-PETITIONERS.

G.R. No. 175049 | 2008-11-27

DECISION
 
CHICO-NAZARIO, J.:
 
This is a Petition for Review on Certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court, seeking (a) the reversal of the Resolution[1] dated 13 July 2005 of the Twenty-Second (22nd) Division of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 00365, which dismissed the Special Civil Action for Prohibition, Declaration of Nullity of Emancipation Patents, Injunction with Prayer for the Issuance of a Temporary Restraining Order; and (b) the reversal of the Resolution[2] of the Twenty-First (21st) Division of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 00365 dated 22 September 2006, which denied the Motion...