Back

National Federation of Sugar Workers (NSFW) vs. Ovejera 114 SCRA 389 [SEPARATE OPINIONS]

NATIONAL FEDERATION OF SUGAR WORKERS (NFSW), petitioner, vs. ETHELWOLDO R. OVEJERA, CENTRAL AZUCARERA DE LA CARLOTA (CAC), COL. ROGELIO DEINLA, as Provincial Commander, 3311st P.C. Command, Negros Occidental, respondents.

G.R. No. L-59743 | 1982-05-31

Separate Opinions

MAKASIAR, J., concurring:

Concurs in the separate opinion of qualified concurrence as to the illegality of the strike and of dissent as to the interpretation of Presidential Decree No. 851 submitted by the Chief Justice.

FERNANDO, CJ., concurring:

With qualifications on the questions of the legality of the strike and dissenting on the interpretation to be accorded Presidential Decree No. 851 on the thirteenth-month additional pay.,

There is at the outset due acknowledgmen t on my part of the high quality of craftsmanship in the opinion of the Court penned by Justice Efren Plana. It is distinguished by its lucidity. There is...