Back

Sps. Maliones vs. Timario, Jr.

SPOUSES ROBLES AND ROSE MALIONES A.K.A. ROSA MALIONES, SPOUSES EDUARDO AND ROSITA QUIÑO, MR. EUGENIO SAWATE, THE LATE GEORGE BATI-EL REPRESENTED BY HIS WIFE LILIA BATI-EL, PETITIONERS, VS. MARIO S. TIMARIO, JR., GABRIEL B. LANTEC, JANICE A. BIAG, FELICIANA C. LAUS, OPLEN SAGA-OC, NARCISA VICENTE, GLORIA G. POLON, LUNESA V. TANY, EVELIO ANDY S. TIMARIO, OCTAVIO A. LESKING, ROEL G. NGOLOBAN, NESTOR BUTENG, CYNTHIA G. POLON, WILLIAM SAD-ANG, CERILO BAOIDANG, JR., ADAM SIMULTOG, ELENA ATOLBA, DUX ALLEN P. ANNAGUEY, RYDEL LANTEC, MARIO PAGTAN, SUANI M. COPICOP, CAMILLE* CAYABAS, JUN M. WITAWIT, GEORGE DADAY, JOHN IT-ITAN, TOMAS O. BANGSOY, CRISPIN B. MANGANGEY, THELMA L. LACYOD, EVA TONGTONGDAN, MATHEW W. KIYAWAN, MIRANDA L. BINGCOLA, FERDINAND SUDICALAN, IAN C. DAMEG, DOMINGO MONTES, BENJAMIN MALONA, DAVYNE ART KIDIT, JESSAMINE TIMARIO, HELEN T. NGITEYEB, LAURENCE M. VIERNES AND CAESAR LAPICTO BALACWID, RESPONDENTS. G.R. N0. 258836 [FORMERLY UDK-16868] SPOUSES ROBLES AND ROSE MALIONES A.K.A. ROSA MALIONES; SPS. EDUARDO AND ROSITA QUIÑO; MR. EUGENIO SAWATE; THE LATE GEORGE BATI-EL; DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES REPRESENTED BY THE OFFICE OF THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR CAR ENGR. RALPH C. PABLO; DPA, EN. P.; PROVINCIAL ASSESSOR OF MOUNTAIN PROVINCE, REPRESENTED BY THE ASSISTANT PROVINCIAL ASSESSOR ENGR. RANDY B. TICCHAP; MUNICIPAL ASSESSOR OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF SABANGAN, MOUNTAIN PROVINCE, REPRESENTED BY ENGR. GABRIEL M. SAWATE; AND THE PUNONG BARANGAV OF DATA, SABANGAN, MOUNTAIN PROVINCE HON. MARIANITO A. CABAN-OS, PETITIONERS, VS. MARIO SOMEBANG TIMARIO, JR., GABRIEL B. LANTEC, JANICE A. BIAG, FELECIANA* C. LAUS, OPLEN SAGA-OC, NARCISA VICENTE, GLORIA G. POLON, LUMESA* V. TANY, EVELIO ANDY S. TIMARIO, OCTAVIO A. LESKING, ROEL C. NGOLOBAN, NESTOR BUTENG, CYNTHIA G. POLON, WILLIAM SAD-ANG, CERILO BAO-IDANG,* JR., ADAM SIMULTOG, ELENA ATOLBA, DUX ALLEN P. ANNAGUEY, RYDEL LANTEC, MARIO PAGTAN, SUANI M. COPICOP, CAMILLA CAYABAS, JUN M. WITAWIT, GEORGE DADAY, CRISELDA BIMOYAG, JOHN IT­ITAN, TOMAS O. BANGSOY, CRISPIN B. MANGANGEY, THELMA L. LACYOD, EVA TONGTONGDAN, MATTHEW W. KIYAWAN, MIRANDA L. BINGCOLA, FERDINAND SUDICALAN, IAN C. DAMEG, DOMINGO G. MONTES, BENJAMIN MALONA, DAVYNE ART KIDIT, JESSAMINE P. TIMARIO, HELEN TOGPA-AN NGITEYEB, LAURENCE MOYAEN VIERNES AND CAESAR LAPICTO BALACWID, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 252834 | 2023-02-06

D E C I S I O N
 

LOPEZ, J., J.:

This Court resolves two consolidated Petitions for Review on Certiorari[1] filed under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court assailing the Decision[2] and the Resolution[3] of the Court of Appeals (CA), which denied the appeal of Spouses Robles and Rose Maliones (Spouses Maliones), Spouses Eduardo and Rosita Quiño (Spouses Quiño), George Bati-el (Bati-el), and Eugenio Sawate (Sawate) (collectively referred to as Spouses Maliones et al.).
 

The Antecedents


The case involved a parcel of land situated in Am-amoting, Batacang/Ambango in Brgy. Data, Sabangan, Mountain Province...