Back

Bun vs. Fabre [SEPARATE OPINION, DISSENTING, PERFECTO, J.]

LAO TANG BUN (alias VICENTE UY), NG BUN HO (alias ONG CHI BEN) LU BON KING (alias LEE), YAP LIM SUN (alias PIA UY), and GAN PING (alias TANG ENG TIAN), petitioners, vs. ENGRACIO FABBE, JESUS BAUTISTA, and OSCAR ARANETA, Commissioners of Immigration, and THE CHIEF OF POLICE, City of Manila, Philippines, respondents.

G.R. No. L-1673 | 1948-10-22

DISSENTING

PERFECTO, J.:

Petitioners allege that they are unlawfully restrained of their liberties, confined in the Grace Park Hotel, Caloocan, and are about to be deported from this country; that the cause of their detention is the decision of the Board of Commissioners of the Bureau of Immigration issued on September 26, 1947, wherein petitioners were ordered to be deported in accordance with the Philippine Immigration Act No. 613 of 1940, supplemented by a warrant of deportation issued on the sane day by respondent commissioners and committed to the deportation office of the Bureau of Immigration.

Petitioners allege that a grave abuse of...