Back

Danilo Q. Militante, Et Al. Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

DANILO Q. MILITANTE, BERNARDINO O. TEJADA, MIGUEL C. SALONGA, ALEJANDRO FRANCISCO, EFREN AYAG, LORENZOABAREDES, OSCAR ABLANIDA, REYNALDO ACIERTO, NORBERTO AFABLE, CESAR AGARAO, ARCANGEL ALCOY, ROQUE ALDE, ANACLETO ALDON, JUANITO ALEJANDRIA, ERNESTO ALMARINES, MAMERTO ANCIRO, TRONILO ANDAYA, JOSE ANG, AMADOR APILADO, WILSON AGUILAR, TOMAS AQUINO, ORLANDO ARANDA, RAMON ARCALES, ROMEO ARGUELLES, VIRGILIO ARAGO, SOFRONIO ARIETA, RAYMUNDO ARMADA, FERNANDO AROMIN, SALVADOR ASPIRAS, JULIAN AUX, RODOLFO ABARILLES, SANTOS ARCENILLA, ROSENDO AGUINALDO, ROMEO ABLANIDA, CELSO ALAC, INIGO ABANG, DANIEL BABICA, BONIFACIO BAJADE, PEPITO BALBERO, ROMEO BALBERO, APOLONIO BALDIVIA, LEONARDO BALTES, PEDRO BALTES, JAIME BANGKAYA, NARCISO BANGOT, DOMINGO BARALLAS, BASILIO BARRERA, MANUEL BENEBE, EDILBERTO BERMUDEZ, ARTEMIO BETANIO, NICOLAS BIATON, GREGORIO BONIFACIO, ANDRES BOQUIREN, SANTIAGO BRECINO, JACINTO BUHAY, RUBEN BUNAO, MANUELITO BUSA, PABLITO BUSTILLO, ARTEMIO BATILARAN, ANGELO BALTES, DIONISIO BORRES, FELICIANO CABALQUINTO, DOMINGO CABENELA, JR. LEONCIO CAINDOY, CONRADO CALCES, MARIANO CALLA, RODEL CALLA, ABELARDO CAMBARE, PACIANO CAMIO, GIL CARANTO, SOLOMON CASTANEDA, JESUS CAWILI, ANTONIO CAYETANO, CESAR CELIS, JOSE CENETA, CECILIO CES, ROMEO CES, BENTIO CHING, JOSE COLAPO, ROMULO CONDE, SANTOS CONDE, WIFREN CORTEZ, SOFRONIO COSE, GENARO COSMOD, EDUARDO CUNANAN, LEODEGARO CURITANA, SALVADOR CUSTODIO, LUCIANO CUTOR, RUBEN CARINO, ANTONIO CAANGAY, FORTUNATO CALIZON, HERMINIO CADIZ, ERNANI CALALAS, PERFECTO CABALLERO, DANTE DAANG, FLORENTE DACQUEL, BENJAMIN DATILES, ROBERTO DE CASTRO, REYNALDO DE DUQUE, ANTHONY DE LA CRUZ, ROLANDO DE LA CRUZ, ROGELIO DE LA ROSA, OSCAR DEL CASTILLO, VICENTE DE LEON, LAMBERTO DE LOS REYES, RENATO DE LOS SANTOS, JOSE DEL RIO, CONRADO DEL ROSARIO, ERNESTO DERECHO, MANUEL DESIDERIO, LAUREANO DEYMOS, REYNALDO DIAZ, CESAR DIEGOR, EDGARDO DIMAANDAL, RENATO DIZON, VIRGILIO DIZON, ANTONIO DOMINGUEZ, GODOFREDO DURANTE, JULIAN DOLOGIN, RUBEN DE LOS REYES, WILDREDO ECHAGUE, ELEAZAR EDAR, RODOLFO ELIANG, LUIS ENRIQUEZ, BIENVENIDO ESPALLARDO, JOVENCIO ESPANOL, EDUARDO ESPINO, REYNALDO ESPINOSA, WILFREDO ESPINOSA, NORBERTO ESTANIL, PRUDENTE ESTO, LEOCADIO ESTRADA, HENRY EVANGELISTA, JOEY ELARDO, RUBEN FABILLAR, MARIO FELICIANO, FORFIRIO FERMO, ALEJANDRO FRANCISCO, ARSENIO FUENTES, BASILIO FUERTES, LORETO FULO, ANDRES FLORENDO, EUGENIO FRANCISCO, ROSENDO FRANCISCO, NAPOLEON FERNANDEZ, TEOTIMO GALERA, EFREN GAN, MANUEL GARCIA, TEOFILO GARCIA, AGAPITO GARON, ROGELIO GEBANA, FLORENCIO GLORIA, ANTONIO GONZAGA, JR., ALEXANDER GONZALES, OSCAR GORGOD, TROADIO GALBISO, JESSE GUIRREY, LUDUVICO GARINGO, CARLITO DUARTE, ALLAN HARTPENCE, BOLIFACIO HENRY, MAURO HERMO, ROGELIO HICETA, ROGELIO HIDALGO, ROLANDO GOJAR, ANTONIO DONGSAL, JUAN INANO, JOSE INGALLA, PEDRO IRONAN, LEONARDO ISIP, RENATO ISIP, ARTEMIO JALDO, LEVY JARQUE, PEDRO JASMIN, JAIME JAVIER, LITO LABABO, WILSON LACRA, JOSE LAGUILLES, ERNESTO LAPIRA, ALFRED LAPUT, JOVITO LASAN, NARCISO LAZARTE, JUANITO LEGASPI, VALENZUELA LEVESITO, JUALITO LISTANA, ROMEO LOZADA, FLORO LUMAGBAS, CESAR LUMIARES, OLIMPIO LUPOS, RICARDO MABUTI, JOSE LASALA, ROMEO LADROMA, JAIME JACA, DANIEL LIBERATO, JR., ADRIANO MADISON, DAMIL MADRID, VIRGILIO MAGTALAS, PASCUAL MAHAYHAY, EMILIANO MALIT, JR., DONALD MAMALLAS, PEDRO MANAHON, SUERLITO MANAO, MAXIMO MANUTA, APOLINARIO MARENTES, RAYMUNDO MORTARILLAS, LEONARDO MENDOZA, ROBERTO MERCADO, ROMEO MERCADO, JOSE MESA, JOSE MIJARES, GODOFREDO MILANES, JESUS MIRANDA, ARTURO MISAJON, RODOLFO MOGO, JOSE MOLINO, JUANITO MOTES, BALTAZAE MORERA, ROMEO MANICDAO, ALEJANDRO MIRANDA, DELFIN MAALLO, ANTONIO MORENO, EMMANUEL MACUTAY, PEDRO MANZANO, TERESITO MIJARES, FELIPE MEKITPIKIT, FRANCISCO JAVIER, FRANCIS NAMOCATCAT, BENJAMIN NARAG, VIRGILIO NARBARTE, ERIBERTO NASAYAO, ARESTIDES NATIVIDAD, COSME NESIO, LUCIO NIDEA, ERNESTO NIEGAS, EPIFANIO NINO, DOMINGO NOLASCO, RICARDO NARZOLES, ROQUE NONATO, ALFREDO NAUTAN, MAXIMO OBREGON, FULGENCIO ONSE, ANTERO ORATE, WILFREDO ORBE, RENTO ORIA, EDUARDO ORCILLA, HERNANI OPEDA, FREDDIE PALAAD, RODRIGO PARRENO, SULPICIO PAWAAN, RODOLFO PACANAN, GUILLERMO PADILLA, TEODORICO PAGAL, ANTONIO PALACIO, BENJAMIN PALAROAN, JOSE PALENCIA, FRACISCO PALMERO, ROBERTO PALOMATA, ROMEO PALOMIA, DANILA PAMINTUAN, FLORENTINO PAMOR, PROCESO PANGAN, CRESTINO PASCUA, ROMEO PATIAG, GENESIS PEREZ, ELIGIO PINEDA, FELIX PIGUERRO, VICTORINO PLANA, DAVID POLIQUIT, RAYMUNDO PUSPUS, RODOLFO MORALEDA, BAROLOME GUIAMBAO, RANILLO QUINTANA, HECTOR NAVALASCA, EVARISTO RABINO, PABLO RACE, RAMON RAPI, JESUS RAVILLAS, ROMEO RAZON, WIFREDO ROCOCO, SERGERONIMO RICALDE, FRANCISCO RIVERA, RUBEN RIVERA, LIBERATO ROBLES, MANUEL ROGEL, ERNESTO ROSATASE, RUBEN ROS, PEDRO ROXAS, PACIFICO RUIZ, FELIX RUNES, REYNALDO RAMOS, PETRONILO REYES, SALVADOR MONTANEZ, ADELIO SAGUID, ANTONIO SALES, RONNIE SAPIO, REYNALDO SANTOS, RUFO SALISI, ALFREDO SAYSON, JOSELITO SAPIO, KIEL SABASAN, JUAN SABLON, ALFREDO SACOLLES, NOLITO SADIWA, RIZAL SAGUID, DIODANTE SAILOG, FREDERICO SALAS, JAIME SALCEDO, LAUREANO SALGADO, MENANDRO SALISI, GRACIANO SALUZA, MIGUEL SAMARINGA, CRISOSTOMO SANICO, MARIANO SANICO, CARLITO SANTOS, MARCELO SANTOS, EDUARDO SANTUELE, OSCAR SANTUELE, LEONARDO SAPUNGAN, LUDUVICO, SARANILLO, CONRADO SEBASTIAN, ROMUALDO SELUDO, RODOLFO SILLOGO, EMMANUEL SODSOD, ERNESTO SOLLEZA, FEDERICO SORIANO, JOSE SUMASTRE, EDGAR TABON, IGNACIO TAMPOL, RUBEN TAN, DOMINADOR TARA, LIBERATO TATAD, ALEJANDRO TECSON, FRANCISCO TELOMEROS, PEDRO TEMPLORA, JR., REYNALDO TIERRA, JORGE TINIO, JR., LEOPOLDO TOLENTINO, MANUEL TOMBUCON, DIOLITO TORRENUEVA, OSCAR TRIBUNAL, ERNESTO TUAZON, VICENTE TERADO, LEONARDO VELASQUEZ, NESTOR VENDIVIL, FELIPE VERSOSA, DEMETRIO VERGARA, JUANITO VELARDE, MARIO VENDIVIL, WILFREDO VERDEJO, CARLOS VERGARA, ARTURO VILLAFLOR, JOVENCIO VILLAFLOR, CARLOS VILLAFUERTO, JOSE VILLARDO, RAUL VILLAREAL, MARCELO VINAS, RUBEN VISEN, RODRIGO VISITO, BENEDICTO YTANG, EDUARDO ZINAMAAN, LEVISTO VALENZUELA, BERNARDINO TEJADA, FEDERICO ALBURO, SEVERINO ASUNO, JOSE AREGLO, ANTONIO TEJERA, RENATO ABALAYAN, ALBERTO BETANIO, SANTOS ARSINELIA, WILFREDO BALTAZAR, PEDRO APOLONIO, MANUEL CASPI, MAXIMO CUESTA, EDUARDO DAGUMAN, JULIO DE LEON, REYNALDO DE LA CRUZ, ADRIANO DE LA CRUZ, VICTOR ESPINA, ROBERTO ELIZALDE, CARLOS ESTABILLO, GERONIMO FERNANDEZ, WILFREDO GILOK, JAYSON GARILAO, ROMULADO GERNA, CHARLES HODGES, SOFRONIO ESPERAS, LOWELL ILACIO, ROBERTO HERBUELA, JOEL NAMORO, DOMINGO SALON, ESTEBENSON SALOMON, EDUARDO NOLIDO, ESPIDIO SAPIANDANTE, MODESTO TERCIO, ARTURO LOTERTE, LORETO TAYAM, ROBERTO RIZALDE, MARIO OCAMPO, PEDRO DANCHEZ, EDUARDO VILLARUEL, PASTOR LAZANO, MACARIO PETATE, and LORENZO ABLETES, petitioners, vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, GOLDEN TAXI CAB COMPANY, LORENZO ZAMORA, DONA NENA ZAMORA and DONA PACING ZAMORA, respondents.

G.R. No. 113448 | 1995-07-14

D E C I S I O N


QUIASON, J.:

This is a petition for certiorari to reverse the Decision of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) in NLRC NCR CA No. 004908-93, affirming the order of the Labor Arbiter which dismissed, for having been barred by prior judgment, NLRC-NCR Cases Nos. 00-01-00618-93, 00-03-01784-93, and 00-03-02073-93.

I
The Golden Taxi Employees and Workers Union - ANGLO (GTEWU-ANGLO), represented by Ernesto Serrano, as union president, filed a case against respondent Golden Taxi Cab Co. (Company) and/or Lorenzo Zamora and Jose Zamora (NLRC-NCR Case No. 00-05-02875-90) for illegal lock-out, violation of B.P. Blg....