Back

[2/2] Commr Andrea Domingo, Bureau Of Immigration vs Herbert Markus Emil Scheer

[2/2] COMMISSIONER ANDREA D. DOMINGO, BUREAU OF IMMIGRATION, petitioner, vs. HERBERT MARKUS EMIL SCHEER, respondent.

G.R. No. 154745 | 2004-01-29

[1] Penned by Associate Justice Edgardo F. Sundiam, with Associate Justices Portia Aliño-Hormachuelos and Elvi John S. Asuncion concurring.

[2] Immigration Commissioner Leandro T. Verceles, Deputy Commissioner Joseph Lopez and Deputy Commissioner Edgar L. Mendoza.

[3] Commissioner Andrea D. Domingo, Associate Commissioners Arthel B. Caronongan, Daniel C. Cueto and Orlando V. Dizon.

[4] Rollo, p. 167.

[5] Id. at 150.

[6] Id. at 151.

[7] Id. at 94.

[8] Id. at 95.

[9] Id. at 88, 171.

[10] Id. at 173.

[11] Id. at 60.

[12] Id. at 59.

[13] Id. at 60-61.

[14] Id. at 60.

[15] Id. at 163.

[16] Id. at 83-86.

[17] Id. at 84-85....