Back

Cecilia Castillo, et al vs Angeles Balinghasay, et al

CECILIA CASTILLO, OSCAR DEL ROSARIO, ARTURO S. FLORES, XERXES NAVARRO, MARIA ANTONIA TEMPLO and MEDICAL CENTER PARA?AQUE, INC., Petitioners, versus ANGELES BALINGHASAY, RENATO BERNABE, ALODIA DEL ROSARIO, ROMEO FUNTILA, TERESITA GAYANILO, RUSTICO JIMENEZ, ARACELI** JO, ESMERALDA MEDINA, CECILIA MONTALBAN, VIRGILIO OBLEPIAS, CARMENCITA PARRENO, CESAR REYES, REYNALDO SAVET, SERAPIO TACCAD, VICENTE VALDEZ, SALVACION VILLAMORA, and HUMBERTO VILLAREAL, Respondents.

G.R. No. 150976 | 2004-10-18

DECISION 

QUISUMBING, J.: 

  For review on certiorari is the Partial Judgment[1] dated November 26, 2001 in Civil Case No. 01-0140, of the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Parañaque City, Branch 258. The trial court declared the February 9, 2001, election of the board of directors of the Medical Center Parañaque, Inc. (MCPI) valid. The Partial Judgment dismissed petitioners' first cause of action, specifically, to annul said election for depriving petitioners their voting rights and to be voted on as members of the board. 

The facts, as culled from records, are as follows: 

   Petitioners and the respondents are...