Back

Alejandro Danan, et al. vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, et al.

ALEJANDRO DANAN, TIRSO LINGAD, JR., AMADO BELLEZA, CARLITO SANTOS, LADISLAO DANAN, RUBEN SAMBAT, RODRIGO DANAN, ABEDNIDO DANAN, FELIX ESCUETA, ROMEO TALA, ADELOMO BALUYOT, PEDRO TALA, RUBEN MANGANTI, PAQUITO CRUZ, RICARDO DIMA-RUCUT, RUFINO DEL ROSARIO, MARCOS PANGAN, LAURA MANIAGO, LAMBERTO DANAN, FLORNARDO MANANSALA, DOMINADOR ARTOLA, ROBERTO ZU?IGA, JR., JOSE MENDOZA, ROMAN BERNAL, BENEDICTO DANAN, JOEL DANAN, RODRIGO PAULE, JIMMY MANALAC, FELICIANO MACASPAC, MARIANO MANANSALA, SILVESTRE MANUEL, FAUSTINO PANGAN, FLORENCIO PANGAN, CONRADO CARLOS, RODRIGO PANGAN, MAXIMINIANO DANAN, PESCASIO DIMARUCUT, DANIEL DANAN, LUCIANO MANLAPAZ, ARMANDO DANAN, FELICIANO MALLARI, REYNALDO MUSNI, RODEL ZUNIGA, SOTERO MONTEMAYOR, RICARDO DANAN, ALFREDO MORALES, JESUS NUNAG, ABRAHAM MANUYAG, PEDRO MERCADO, OSCAR MANALILI, FORTUNATO MANUEL, ROSITA BERNAL, RUBEN MIRANDA, NICOLAS MANANSALA, JOSE MANLAPAZ, JR., DIOSDADO LINGAD, MONICA TALA, JULIE CORTES, ANDRES PAULE, RONNIE PAULE, CARLITO AGUILUS, ROMEO BALINGIT, BENIGNO PORTALES, ARNEL SAMBAT, ALFREDO ALFARO, ROMEO ALFARO, FELICIANO BUCAD, SR., ONADAB ISIP, CARLITO DIMACALI, JAIME BAUTISTA, ELIAS BALINGIT, REMY CARLOS, MARIANO SANTOS, FEDERICO MANLAPAZ, REYNALDO SANTOS, ADELAIDA CALMA, GREGORIO CALMA, PEPITO ALFARO, FERNANDO MANANSALA, JOE RAMMIE EMILIA, ROGELIO CORTES, DOMINADOR MALIT, ELPIDIO TALA, RODRIGO TALA, SALVADOR TALA, ROMEO TALA, REMEO DANAN, EDUARDO DANAN, CWZAR DANAN, BENJAMIN PANGAN, DOMINGO SUMANDAL, MOISES SUSI, RODOLFO GERVACIO, SR., RODOLFO GERVASIO, JR., JESUS BERNAL, ALFREDO SANTOS, FORTUNATO DANAN, FRANCISCO MACASPAC, EDWIN MACASPAC, FELICISIMO MACASPAC, DIOSDADO MACASPAC, REYNALDO TIMBANG, EULOGIO MACASPAC, RICARDO CHAVEZ, RUBEN MANUYAG, DELFIN TALA, TOMAS PAULE, CLARO SUBA, DIOSDADO FLORES, FRANCISCO NORALES, VENANCIO FLORES, DANTE FLORES, AGUSTIN ARIOLA, RICARDO ARIOLA, ARTEMIO FLORES, FELICIANO BUCOD, JR., ROLANDO SERRANO, JUANITO LINTAG, TOMAS TALA, LEONARDO RONQUILLO, LAMBERTO TALA, RICARDO LINGAD, ANOTNIO SANTOS, IGNACIO TRESVALLES, ERNESTO PITUC, TEOFILO MUNOZ, BIENVENIDO BELLEZA, MANUEL MAGUIAT, OFELIA MIGUEL, PEDRO TALA, ALEJANDRO TALA, RODRIGO SERRANO, FRANCISCO BERNARTE, OSCAR SERRANO, CONSOLACION SERRANO, CEZAR SERRANO, JOSE BERNARTE, JESUS BERNARTE, CALIXTO SERRANO, ROBERTO MALLARI, ARNOLD PATRICIA, REYNALDO OSBUAL, WILFREDO TAPALLA, ELIZALDE FAPREQUILAN, REYNALDO CASTRO, LUISITO MALLARI, ANTONIO CASTRO, MARCELO MANANSALA, MARFELA AQUINO, HERMOGENES LACAP, VIRGILIO MANANSALA, NESTOR DATU, ROMEO DATU, ALEGRIA BELLEZA, PURITA MIRANDO, MARIA PEREZ, ALBERTO DELA CRUZ, ARTURO DELA CRUZ, GENERITO TALA, CELESTINO TAPALLA, JIMMY TAPALLA, MIKE TAPALLA, REMIGIO OSBUAL, MYRNA MIGUEL, EDUARDO ESCUETA, CONRADO MALLARI, AVELINO MIGUEL, VICTORINO TALA, IGNACIO DELA CRUZ, ROLANDO OSBUAL and ROLANDO MASANQUE, Petitioners, versus THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS and ESTRELLA ARRASTIA, Respondents.

G.R. No. 132759 | 2005-10-25

D E C I S I O N 


Tinga, J.: 

This deals with two separate Rule 45 petitions, later consolidated, filed by the Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board ("DARAB") and Alfredo Danan, et al. Both petitions seek the reversal of the Court of Appeals' Decision in CA-G.R. SP No. 33796, which reversed and set aside the DARAB Decision in DARAB Case No. 1551 and its Resolution denying petitioners' motion for reconsideration. 

Petitioners ("private petitioners") in G.R. No. 132759 are all residents of Lubao, Pampanga, claiming to be cultivating a vast landholding owned by the heirs of Teodorica Reinares Arrastia, Leticia Arrastia...