Back

Estate of Tarcila vda. de Villegas vs. Jesus R. Gaboya, et al

ESTATE OF TARCILA VDA. DE VILLEGAS, Petitioner, versus JESUS R. GABOYA, JOSE CUENCO BORROMEO, and RICARDO V. REYES, in their capacity as Administrators of the Intestate Estate of Vito Borromeo, CESAR GILLAMAC, in his capacity as the Register of Deeds of Cebu City, PILAR N. VDA. DE BORROMEO, MARIA B. PUTONG, FEDERICO V. BORROMEO, JOSE BORROMEO, CONSUELO V. BORROMEO, CANUTO V. BORROMEO, JR., PATROCINIO B. HERRERA, EMILIO A. BORROMEO, JR., CORAZON A. BORROMEO, EDUARDO BORROMEO, TOMAS BORROMEO, AMELIA BORROMEO, COSME BORROMEO, PETRA C. BORROMEO, JOSE ANTONIO BORROMEO, VITALIANA BORROMEO VDA. DE LEONTING, JOSE C. BORROMEO, FORTUNATO BORROMEO, AMELINDA B. TALAM, ANGELITA BORROMEO, MARIA B. VDA. DE REUNILLA, JOSEFINA BORROMEO NERI, PRESCILLANO TITO BORROMEO, AMELIA R. BORROMEO, ESTATE OF SALUD BORROMEO, MARIA B. ATEGA, SISTER ROSARIO BORROMEO, SISTER LUZ BORROMEO, HERMINIGILDA NONNENKAMP, FE BORROMEO QUEROS, HON. FERNANDO RUIZ, HON. NUMERIANO ESTENZO, ATTY. FILIBERTO LEONARDO, ATTY. NAZARIO PACQUIAO, ATTY. CIPRIANO RACAZA, ATTY. EMILIO BENITEZ, JR., ATTY. CASTOR Y. HONTANOSAS, ATTY. BENJAMIN RALLON, ATTY. CALIXTO P. VALLENTE, ATTY. GAUDISIO C. VILLAGONZALO, HON. ALFREDO BENIPAYO, ATTY. CESAR GONZALES, ATTY. NICOLAS JUMAPAO, ATTY. RAUL SESBRENO, ATTY. MIGUEL CUENCO, ATTY. FILEMON FERNANDEZ, ATTY. QUIRICO DEL MAR, ATTY. DOMINGO ANTIGUA, ATTY. VICENTE JAYME, ATTY. ROSARIO DE JESUS ALANO, AMPARO MERCADO ZOSA, ATTY. FRANCIS ZOSA, ANGELO ZOSA, LORNA ZOSA, ZONIA ZOSA, NORA ZOSA, ROLANDO ZOSA, ELBERT ZOSA, EVELYN ZOSA, JOCELYN ZOSA, MANUEL ZOSA, JR., and MA. LOURDES ZOSA, Respondents.

G.R. No. 143006 | 2006-07-14

SECOND DIVISION

DECISION 

AZCUNA, J.: 

This is a petition for review on certiorari of the Resolutions of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. CV No. 57852 promulgated on July 28, 1999 and April 18, 2000. The Resolution dated July 28, 1999 dismissed petitioner's appeal, while the Resolution dated April 18, 2000 denied petitioner's motion for reconsideration. 

The antecedents are as follows: 

Vito Borromeo and Juliana Evangelista were husband and wife. Juliana died intestate on August 13, 1939, while Vito died on March 13, 1952. They had no children but left extensive properties in the province of Cebu. 

Special Proceedings...