Back

[2/2] Vivian Locsin, et al. Vs. the Hon. Sandiganbayan, et al

[2/2] VIVIAN Y. LOCSIN, YAO SHIONG SHIO, OSCAR MANUEL, RAMON LINAN, PAZ Y. FLORES, for and on their own behalf, and SIXTO O. RACELIS, for and on behalf of ORIENTAL PETROLEUM AND MINERAL CORPORATION, Petitioners, versus THE HONORABLE SANDIGANBAYAN, PRESIDENTIAL COMMISSION ON GOOD GOVERNMENT, ASSET PRIVATIZATION TRUST, REV. EMETERIO BARCELON, S.J., EDUARDO F. HERNANDEZ, GUILLERMO PABLO, JR., AMPARO BARCELON, ANTONIO CAGUIAT, RAMON A. PEDROSA, JAIME L. LEDESMA, SIMPLICIO J. ROXAS, VALERIANO FUGOSO, WILFREDO SA?ARES, ULTRANA MINERALS CORP., INDEPENDENT REALTY CORP., PERFORMANCE INVESTMENT CORP., MID-PASIG LAND DEVELOPMENT CORP., FABIAN VER, PIEDRAS PETROLEUM CORP., and RIZAL COMMERCIAL BANKING CORPORATION, Respondents.

G.R. No. 146941 | 2007-08-09

No Forum Shopping and res judicata

Respondents Hernandez, Roxas, and the PMO raise the issues of forum shopping and res judicata in their comments, arguing
that this petition be denied as petitioners are guilty of forum shopping and that res judicata already applies. Said
respondents allege that the following cases were concealed by petitioners:

a. SEC Case No. 1690 and SEC Case No. 1708, Alex Realty, Celso Fernandez, et al. vs. Oriental Petroleum, Yao Shiong
Shio, et al.;

b. Civil Case No. 55427, RTC-Pasig, Oriental Petroleum, Yao Shiong Shio, Oscar Manuel, et al. vs. PCGG and Fr. Barcelon;

c. Civil Case No. 88-14, RTC-Makati,...