Back

torola Philippines, Inc. et al. Vs. Imelda B. Ambrocio et al.

MOTOROLA PHILIPPINES, INC. and/or SCG PHILIPPINES, INC., ROMERICO S. SERRANO, DANIEL JAVELOSA, ALFRED GAMBOL, ANN DALUPAN and JOSEPH JACOBSON, Petitioners, versus IMELDA B. AMBROCIO, AMELITA ALAO, MERLE ALMASCO, LIBRADA C. ACEBES, ELVIRA C. ANULAT, FE ARAGON, CARINA D. ARGAME, MA. TERESA R. ALMARIO, ISIDORA S. ALMENDRAS, ARLENE C. ALINDAY, EDNA B. ASIATICO, SUSANA AGUILON, MELINDA A. BALLON, ANNABELLA T. BRAVO, FEROLYN H. BACO, LOIDA A. BONSOL, MA. LUISA L. BONAOBRA, TERESITA BELBES, EMILIANA C. CARRAO, MA. CRISTINA L. CARINO, ERLINDA T. CARIGMA, DAISY E. CAPUNO, IMELDA S. CAGUIOA, AMELIA E. CASTRO, ROSEMARIE B. CASICAS, CARMELITA B. CASTILLO, FLORA O. CABRERA, MERLINDA B. CAJILIG, CRISELDA D. CAINGLET, ROSITA B. CERBAS, MA. VICTORIA R. CERRER, MARILOU T. COSCOS, SILVIA S. CUNANAN, PERLITA CIELO, TERESITA B. CRUZ, LUZVIMINDA E. CELIS, RUFINA T. CRUZ, YOLANDA D. CONSTANTINO, ANABELEN CANAPI, JOCELYN CHALAN, MAYDELYN C. DAYAO, ERLINDA M. DAJAO, BRIGIDA R. DE CHAVEZ, MERLE E. DE LOS SANTOS, CRISTINA C. DUPAYA, CERLY B. DISTOR, YOLANDA A. DIONISIO, GLORIA R. DAIGDIGAN, YOLANDA DE JESUS, HAYDEE G. DE LEON, MERCEDITA M. DELGADO, ROSALINDA B. DEL ROSARIO, CRISTINA D. ENTUCIASMO, EUGENIA G. ENRIQUES, ELIZABETH G. FRANCIA, FLORDELINA B. FLORES, LEDILLA DARDE, ROSALIDAR R. GARCIA, REMEDIOS B. GALMAN, CURINA F. GAMA, ELISA G. GUSTILO, ISABELITA A. GAGARIN, SERENA G. GENTOLLANES, MA. EMELITA T. GUARIN, ANNE C. GONZALES, ARCILLA G. GLORIA, DOROTEA T. HAMILE, RIZALINA CARAMAT, ERLINDA DEUDA, DOMINGA ILAO, NAZARIA P. HERNANDEZ, EDITHA P. JAUDALSO, CELEDONIA LAPUZ, JOSEPHINE T. LAGUNERO, OLIVIA O. LABRADOR, EMELITA G. LEGASPI, WILMA G. LEMONCITO, CARLINA R. LIRAZAN, LUISA R. LOYOLA, JEAN S. LOZANO, MA. TERESA R. LIZARDO, NENA L. MARCELO, CORAZON R. MATEO, GUADALUPE T. MAYNIGO, LOLITA C. MALLILLIN, HELEN Q. MERCADO, TERESITA L. MEDIADO, ERLINDA G. MECUA, EDITHA M. MERCADO, DORIS V. MADARANG, LOIDA G. MALLARI, MARILOU C. MARTINEZ, LUCIA C. MANALO, RUBY M. MAMARIL, ANITA C. MEDALLA, LTA M. MEJIA, MARY A. MINA, GLORIA M. NIEVA, MELINDA F. NOFUENTE, CORAZON B. NUYDA LETICIA R. ORTEGA, ROMEO P. ORTEGA, RAUL R. ORAA, FE P. PASCUA, GLICERIA B. PLACIDO, FELICITAS R. PATO, SYLVIA PERALTA, LENIDA R. PONES, ROSALINDA PAREDES, YOLANDA PANGANIBAN, MARITEL PILASPILAS, CONSOLACION M. QUINOY, FLORANDO C. QUITAIN, ERLINDA I. REYES, ROSENDA S. RAMOS, IRENE G. REGACHO, EMILITA R. REYES, LEONORA A. RIVERA, REMEDIOS M. ROBOSA, MELINDA G. RODULFO, LEPOLDO A. RODRIGUEZ, VERONICA S. RIVERA, NANCY J. ROMERO, TERESITA F. RONQUILLO, EVA B. RUANTO, MARIA LUISA LUY RABIN, ROSITA SABINO, ROSEMARIE J. SALANATIN, MARILIE S. SANCHEZ, OLIVIA C. SANTIOQUE, LUISA R. SAN MIGUEL, JOSEFINA F. SAN MIGUEL, ANGELES C. SAMAR, OLIVIA P. SALLE, NELIA E. SARABILLO, NENITA R. SAFLOR, GLORIA B. SANTIAGO, ANGELINA H. SANTOS, MARINA B. SOLIDUM, MARITESS G. SUNGA, SALVADOR M. SALES, SUSANA C. TAGAM, ARCEL S. TAYAG, JOSEPHINE B. TADIOAN, SILVIA L. TAN, LIGAYA C. TANCINGCO, MARIVIC R. TELEBRICO, ROSELYN B. TERUEL, MARILYN G. TOLENTINO, MARILYN B. TAGUINES, AMALIA UNIPA, MANUEL UNIPA, EMERENCIANA VILLAGONZALO, NINA VILLANUEVA, JOSEPHINE VILLANUEVA, HELEN J. VILLARIN, NELIA VILLANUEVA, ANALYN B. VIDA, CLAUDIA YASAY, GLORIA C. ZAFRA, SYLVIA R. ZAFRA, FLOR G. FUNA, BELEN BANDALAN, ELENA H. SARZUELA, CRISTINA C. BALICOCO, GLORIA C. BALICOCO, GLORIA N. BANOG, REMEGIA DE LOS SANTOS, BEVERLY N. PAYAS, JULIET BUERA, EMERCIANA E. MARCELO, LEONIDA N. QUINTO, AURORA Q. BACUD, ZENAIDA R. MANAHAN, VIVIAN G. PERALTA, CRISANTA ROTONE, LEONILA R. VIRTUS, TERESA ALEGADA, ROSALINA R. AQUINO, JAIME A. AROGO, ELISA C. BARLAS, JULIETA V. BUENAVENTURA, HELEN F. CAMAROA, EDNA C. ESTILLORE, HELINDA H. HAGOOT, LIBERTY B. ISIP, EMERLITA B. LAYNO, ANGELITA C. MACALINDONG, SEVERINA E. MALAGA, VIOLETA C. NACIANCENO, MARITA C. NATIVIDAD, CRISTINA NAVARRO, RODRIGO L. RIVERA, TERESITA C. ROLLON, REMEDIOS C. SANTOS, MILAGROS B. SUNGA, VIDISTA B. TALAVERA, CARMELITA J. TAMPE, VIOLETA P. GUEVARA, AMELITA ILAO, MYRNA A. COMBALECER, CONCHITA V. CONSIBIDO, LIZA MOYA, SUSAN PATARATA, MILA SAMORTIN, BEATRIZ UMALI, EVA BANCOLETA, RIZALINO BANCOLETA, MARIA RIZA BERNI, ELIZABETH SUNGA, IMELDA DE VILLA and MINDA SAN PEDRO, Respondents.

G.R. No. 173279 | 2009-03-30

D E C I S I O N


CARPIO MORALES, J.:

On petition for review on certiorari is the Court of Appeals March 1, 2006 Resolution[1] and June 27, 2006 Resolution[2] reinstating the appeal of respondent Imelda B. Ambrocio and 235[3] other respondents from the December 13, 2004 Resolution[4] and September 30, 2005 Resolution[5] of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) in NLRC RAB IV Case Nos. 4-13771-01-C, and 4-13772-01-C.

Culled from the five-volume records of the case are the following undisputed facts:

Sometime in 1997, Motorola Philippines, Inc. (MPI), a subsidiary of Motorola U.S., decided to close its Parañaque plant in...